MORTGAGES

A mortgage grants a lender (the ‘mortgagee’) rights against the yacht itself (known as rights ‘in rem’), rather than just against the owner (the ‘mortgagor’) in the event of default. While it still needs to be beefed-up by other types of security, such as covenants, and assignments of earnings and insurances, the mortgage is the most important type of security taken by a lender. Mortgages over yachts are known as ship mortgages to distinguish them from real estate mortgages. A mortgage can be taken over the whole yacht or just a number of the 64 available shares.

MORTGAGE REGISTRATION

The mortgagee’s power to sell the yacht in the event of default is specifically granted by statute. A mortgage is said to be ‘statutory’ where it has been set out and registered as prescribed by statute (in this case, regulation 57 of, Merchant Shipping (Registration of Ships) Regulations 1993 (SI 1993/3138) and paragraph 7 of Schedule 1 to the Merchant Shipping Act 1995. Otherwise, they are known as ‘common law’ mortgages but these are very unusual. A statutory mortgage can only be created over a yacht registered under Part I (but not the Part III ‘Small Ships Register’).

The mortgagee will likely use a Form 4736 ‘Account Current’ statutory mortgage to secure not just the principal sum and interest but also costs and expenses. A Notice of Mortgage Intent MSF 4739 can be lodged in advance in order to record as early a date as possible for the mortgage: this is important when establishing the priority of debts in the event of later default.

The mortgage is a brief document, just setting out the names of the parties, details of the yacht, and a short description of the secured obligation with reference to the agreement and the deed of covenant that supplements the mortgage. It must be lodged with the Registrar General of Shipping and Seamen, and the relevant fee paid. The Registrar will the register and returned the mortgage document.

Where the mortgagor is a company registered in England and Wales, then, by virtue of section 860 of the Companies Act 2006, details of the statutory mortgage, the deed of covenant and any other security documents must be sent to the Registrar of Companies within 21 days, failing which such documents will be void as against a creditor, liquidator or administrator.

COVENANTS & ASSIGNMENTS

As the mortgage document itself is so brief, and there’s no scope for amending or adding to it, and also as the mortgage attaches to the yacht rather than the owner, it must be supplemented by covenants and assignments. Covenants dictate various dos and don’ts, and may be set out in the loan agreement and/or separately in a deed of covenant according to the lender’s house style. Assignments transfer rights from one party to another. The remainder of this article considers common covenants and assignments. For convenience, it is assumed that all covenants are set out in a deed.

Unlike mortgages, deeds of covenant, and any other collateral security documents, cannot be registered with the Registrar of Ships.

NON-STATUTORY MORTGAGE

While a deed supports the mortgage, deeds can still have a clause by which the yacht is mortgaged. This is needed as a backup in case the statutory mortgage is invalid – which can be the case where, for example, the mortgage hasn’t been registered with the Companies Register. The deed will create a non-statutory mortgage which, while better than nothing, won’t be enforceable against a buyer who buys in good faith and isn’t aware of the mortgage, and will be ranked below a statutory mortgage should the mortgagor default.

YACHT REGISTRATION

The mortgagor will promise in the deed the yacht will be registered as a ship in the United Kingdom, and will remain, so, under the same registered name, for as long as the yacht is mortgaged. This is necessary as UK Part I ship registrations expire after only five years unless renewed.

CHARGE REGISTRATION

The deed will require, where the owner is a company registered in England or Wales, the mortgage to be registered as a charge with the United Kingdom companies register (known as Companies House). This is fallback requirement as the mortgagee isn’t going to leave anything to chance and will (or should) have registered the mortgage as soon as possible as not doing so risks the mortgagee loosing both the security and priority.

INSURANCE

Arguably just as important as the mortgage is the borrower’s covenants in respect of insurance, and policy assignments. In particular, the borrower covenants to:

• At the borrower’s expense, insure the yacht, for a value, on terms, and with an underwriter(s), all agreed with the lender.

• Comply with all policy terms throughout the term of the loan, including, of course, prompt payment of insurance premiums.

• Renew policies as needed to maintain cover.

• Not settle a claim without the lender’s consent

It’s not only the yacht itself which must be insured, but third party liabilities which, if not satisfied, will expose the yacht itself to claims which might rank higher than the lender’s as mortgagee. Particular risks must also be covered, such as war risks, and mortgagee’s interest insurance. The latter provides cover where a failing on the borrower’s part means that other policies are rendered ineffective.

For larger yachts, the policies must be assignable to the lender, and confirmation will have to be provided by underwriters that such assignments are noted on the policies and that proceeds of the insurance will be paid to the lender if necessary. For smaller yachts, it may be sufficient for the lender to be named as a co-assured on the policy.

CLASSIFICATION SOCIETY

An explanation as to the role of classification societies (often known as ‘class’) can be found here. Assuming the yacht must be classed, if the yacht isn’t maintained and surveyed as Class Rules stipulate, the yacht is said to be ‘out of class’ – which can lead to insurance policies being invalidated, as well as the yacht not being maintained properly. As this would jeopardise the mortgagee’s security, the deed of covenant will stipulate maintenance in class.

REGULATORY COMPLIANCE

Depending on the yacht’s length, gross tonnage and whether it’s registered for chartering, it will be subject to various regulations which help ensure it’s used safely. Here’s a summary of those affecting your yacht. As well as being detained by port officials, non-compliance can render insurances void, which has obvious implications for the mortgagee’s financial security. Compliance with such regulations will be a key provision.

INSPECTION

As Class rules and flag state regulations only help to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the yacht, the mortgagee will want to have the opportunity to inspect the vessel to ensure that aesthetic aspects, and with them much of her value, are also being maintained. The mortgagee must therefore have a right to inspect, and this can be supported by a specific minimum value.

MANAGEMENT

While ‘yacht management’ can cover a broad spectrum of support services, regulations may require management of a specific type and quality, failing which the vessel may be off-cover for insurance purposes and liable to detention following a port state inspection. Managers also vary in approach and quality. Unsurprisingly, therefore, mortgagees will want to approve which manager is appointed.

OPERATIONS

The mortgagee may wish to restrict the movement of the yacht, not only by stipulating that she is to be kept out of waters close to areas known for piracy or adjacent to unstable countries, but also away from areas where actions in the event of default may be difficult or impractical. It may also be necessary for the deed to spell out that the yacht is to be used in a legal way – for example, not chartering out where the yacht is not registered as a commercial vessel and insured accordingly.

CHARTERING

An assignment of chartering income (if any) can be a helpful tool for a lender looking to recoup money, especially while awaiting the sale of a yacht in the event of default. Written notice will need to be served on the charterers – which can be commercially awkward for the borrower and a good incentive to keep on track with loan repayments.

INCIDENTS

Where any kind of incident occurs involving the yacht, whether that be a fire, grounding, flooding, or a legal action such as arrest or other formal court proceedings, the mortgagee will want to know right away, and the deed of covenant will reflect this. Crucially, liens can rank higher than a mortgage.

MODIFICATIONS

Refits don’t always improve or even add value to yachts: an owner’s ‘personal stamp’ can adversely affect value and may not even be carried in compliance with regulations. The mortgagee will want to know about, and if necessary veto, any proposed modifications.

DISPOSAL

While obvious, it needs to be set out in the deed of covenant that the mortgagor cannot sell the yacht while it provides security.

COLLATERAL SECURITY

As well as the mortgage and deed of covenant, the lender may want a mortgage or charge over the shares in the yacht owning company, involving share certificates being deposited with the lender, together with signed but undated stock transfers. Going one stage further, the lender may also require a personal guarantee from the beneficial owner.